Part I: Lazzarato’s ‘Indebted Man’

Eleanor Ivory Weber

‘Debt operates not only in the manipulation of enormous quantities of money, in sophisticated financial and monetary policies; it informs and configures techniques for the control and production of users’ existence, without which the economy would not have a hold on subjectivity.’1

I purchased a copy of Maurizio Lazzarato’s The Making of the Indebted Man (La fabrique de l’homme endetté) for $25 at World Food Books earlier this year, at the suggestion of Melbourne artist Lucina Lane, who was working in the shop. I want to pass on this worthy recommendation and use The Making of the Indebted Man as a kind of sustaining pedal to some of the things that might arise during these blog episodes.

The fundamental argument Lazzarato advances is that the ‘debtor-creditor relationship’ is the basis of contemporary social life. The word ‘relationship’ is important, for it insists that the dynamic between the two entails conviction, commitment, character-judgment and, in the end, morals. These days we must indebt ourselves in order to sustain life. Basic needs such as housing, food, education and health exist through a dynamic of credit and debt, and to obtain credit one must prove oneself willing and able to repay (with interest, of course). Increasingly, the onus of proving one can sustain life/repay is placed upon the individual, and yet the state decides which forms of life it will sanction. Property is a prime example, where rather than the question of shelter or even housing, the discourse focuses on the ‘power relations between owners (of capital) and non-owners (of capital).’

A particular kind of subjectivity is thus borne, which accordingly predetermines the routes lives can take. This is the impasse: in order for capital to sustain its stranglehold on individual subjectivity it must indebt us to the point that we have no choice but to reproduce it (through repayments). And if we default, we are not only fiscally but also morally bankrupt.

In order to buy Lazzarato’s book, I used a Visa Debit card to access a bank account identified by a series of numbers associated with that particular piece of plastic. Their validation occurs through my being able to remember the PIN. My identity corresponds to that inscribed in and through the card and, by extension, what the card allows (or doesn’t allow) me to do. Thereby, it manufactures subjectivity. The transaction grants access to an intangible electronic space where a salary (if one is within this sanctioned rubric of time-for-money employment) should regularly find itself via a similar process of numerical assignation, identity evaluation and transference.

Yet all debit cards are arguably elaborate placebos for a universal sickness, as this process above doesn’t need a surplus to function. I could also have taken a credit that day, which effectively sends the bank-computer a very welcome message to the effect of ‘I am bound to pay you back at some later date, plus interest.’ In one fell swoop, the future collapses! It sounds extreme, but imagine if I’d taken a mortgage. Or think about what it means to study at university these days; one takes a credit in order to study in order to secure a place in a job that will enable you to pay off the fact you had to study to get a job. What does all this mean for the very concept of future, and the possibility of the new and non-preconceived?

‘Granting credit requires one to estimate that which is inestimable – future behavior and events – and to expose oneself to the uncertainty of time. The system of debt must therefore neutralize time, that is, the risk inherent to it. It must anticipate and ward off every potential “deviation” in the behavior of the debtor the future might hold.’

Through neoliberal ideology, indebtedness becomes wholly commensurate with subjectivity, and Margaret Thatcher’s curse fulfils itself. Rather than society being a collectively agreed-upon formulation of laws and rights, which are upheld by a (more or less) democratically elected government accountable to its constituencies, a situation arises where the moral course of action is to ‘take upon oneself the costs of economic and financial disaster’. In other words, a reversal of democracy comes to pass whereby individuals are responsible for what government~finance externalises onto a society it rejects per se.

What can this mean for political life? How can we divert capitalism from its warpath when representational democracy itself has been subjugated to the whims of finance and terror-management? How do we take responsibility for our collective lives, our society: through absorbing the quasi-moralism of the exponents of the debtor-creditor relation, or by becoming truly immoral?

 


 

1. All quotes from Maurizio Lazzarato, The Making of the Indebted Man, Semiotext(e) 2012 (trans. from the French by Joshua David Jordan)

News Archive

RUNWAY REGIONAL TRAVEL BURSARIES: Be our Cementa17 reporter!

CALLOUT FOR PROPOSALS: Issue #33 Power

Love art? Got skillz? Runway Board Member Call Out for 2017

RUNWAY <3 LIVEWORKS // writers workshop callout

FAIRFIELD FOOD SAFARI // presented by Runway and PYT

RUNWAY REGIONAL TRAVEL BURSARIES

Tribunal: a review

Callout: Runway issue #32[RE/PRODUCTION]

On the threatened closure of Sydney College of the Arts

In Response: A carving out of space that is designed to end

In Response: Community, Criticality and Play

In Response: Strength in ARI Diversity

Callout: Runway issue #31[WEST]

In Response: Revisiting a Melbourne Perspective

“The party becomes the site of knowing”: on the Brisbane sharehouse ARI

The Lifecycle and Deathcycle of ARIs

One year in an ARI

Balancing on the Edge: A Melbourne Perspective

Les Bijoux Indiscrets

On the marginalisation of female pleasure

An account of my encounters with porn

Introducing our guest blogger for issue #29[PORN]: Emily Post Coitus

On Reenacting ‘Dream Merchant’

CALLOUT FOR RUNWAY ISSUE #30 [ECOLOGIES]

Conversations 6

Conversations 5

Conversations 4

Conversations 3

Runway is looking for 4 new board members for 2016!

Conversations 2

Conversations 1

CALLOUT FOR RUNWAY ISSUE #29 [PORN]

Lauren Reid and Vaida Stepanovaité discuss the Project Space Festival in Berlin

The Politics of Listening

A list of other jobs artists do to support their careers as artists.

Australian Artist Run Initiatives condemn cuts to the Australia Council for the Arts

Amina McConvell’s hypnogogic manifestations

Casula

CALLOUT FOR RUNWAY ISSUE #28 [MOVEMENT]

Perth Amboy

Stuart Highway

Wallerawang

GIRLS TO THE FRONT: Hissy Fit

Clandulla

Kandos

Henley Golf Club

Moira National Park

An unusual way of doing politics: Alex Martinis Roe

Strike!

Constructions of the ‘We’

Rights of Nature

The Government Machine

CALLOUT FOR RUNWAY ISSUE #27 [OUTSIDE]

Part VIII: One for the money

Keyboard mash (Caps lock on): Terrence Combos

Part VII: GCC @ KTZ @ FIAC

The Next Big Thing: Reserve your Runway 2014 Artist Edition today

PRESS RELEASE: Become a Founding Member of the Runway Funding Circle

Part VI: Notes on Society, with Susan Gibb

Art can make you soft again: spotlight on Rosie Deacon

Part V: A page on W.A.G.E. (valued at approx. $93.75)

PRESS RELEASE: Runway announces first Annual Commission by Sydney emerging artist Rosie Deacon

Part IV: Some smiles for the Economic Frown

Runway is growing: Callout for new board members

Part III: What is this thing called work?

Regional Contemporary Art Network

Part II: Eyes on the prize

Part I: Lazzarato’s ‘Indebted Man’

CALLOUT FOR RUNWAY ISSUE #26 [KNOWLEDGE]

Introducing guest blogger Eleanor Ivory Weber

“Die Sonne kommt näher”: Otto Piene’s More Sky in Berlin

Fuzzy Logic: Talking Big Data and the Aesthetics of the Infinitely Small at CMA2014

The Pale Fox – Camille Henrot in Copenhagen

Kiribati – Putting a Face to Climate Change

The Flux of Space: Berlin’s Project Space Festival

Guest Editor for Runway Issue#25 – Andrew Hurle

Callout for Runway Issue #25 [MONEY]

8 Propositions for Islands: Part 8

8 Propositions for Islands: Part 7 // Becoming Post-nissological

8 Propositions for Islands: Coda // Those Who Stay

8 Propositions for Islands // Part 5: Island as Island

8 Propositions for Islands // Part 4: Plinth as Island

8 Propositions for Islands // Part 3: Queer Performance as Archipelago

8 Propositions for Islands // Part 2: Stage as Island

8 Propositions for Islands // Part 1: Artist as Island

A Discourse on Prototyping, War Crimes and Artistic Practice

Callout for Issue #24 [ISLANDS]

It’s launch day!

Out with Outsider Art?

21st Century Artist conference, Artspace Sydney, October 2013

Runway’s New Adventure


CONNECT WITH US

Search Runway